Mesh Tape vs. Paper Tape: Best for Inside Corners?

Understanding Mesh Tape and Paper Tape

When it comes to finishing drywall, the choice between mesh tape and paper tape often stirs debate among contractors and DIY enthusiasts alike. Both have their own set of advantages and disadvantages, especially when it comes to inside corners. In this article, we’ll explore expert opinions to help you determine which is best for your project.

Expert Opinions on Mesh Tape

Proponents of mesh tape highlight its ease of use and suitability for various applications. According to Jim Thompson, a seasoned drywall contractor, "Mesh tape is incredibly forgiving. Its adhesive backing allows for quick application, which is a great time-saver when you're working in tight corners.” This makes it an appealing option for those looking to complete their projects more efficiently.

However, Thompson also points out a drawback: "While mesh tape allows for faster application, it can sometimes create issues with feathering and sanding if not applied correctly." This has led many to consider the longevity and durability of the joint when using mesh tape for inner corners.

Expert Opinions on Paper Tape

In contrast, advocates for paper tape argue that it provides a stronger bond in the long run. Sarah Jones, an interior contractor with over a decade of experience, states, "Paper tape, when applied with a proper bedding coat of joint compound, can be incredibly strong and may even outperform mesh tape in the long term." She emphasizes that the ability to embed paper tape firmly into the joint compound is crucial for a successful finish.

Moreover, an important point made by Jones is that paper tape offers better resistance to cracking. "If you’re finishing inside corners that need to endure the test of time, paper tape holds up better against potential movement in the drywall.” This durability makes it a preferred material for many professionals who prioritize long-lasting results.

Comparing Durability and Application Techniques

Durability

When comparing durability, most industry professionals lean toward paper tape for inside corners due to its strength when properly applied. "Mesh tape may seem easier initially, but it does not offer the same level of structural integrity, especially in areas that see a lot of stress," says James Rodriguez, a construction project manager. This highlights the importance of considering the eventual wear and tear of your finished drywall.

Application Techniques

The application process differs greatly between these two types of tape. For mesh tape, it typically involves simply press-fitting the tape into the corner and applying joint compound over it. However, paper tape requires a slightly more nuanced technique. "Using a knife to embed paper tape under joint compound can make a world of difference," notes Amanda Lee, a drywall specialist. “The key is applying a thin layer of mud first, then embedding the tape, ensuring it doesn’t bubble.”

Cost Considerations

Cost is another aspect to consider. While mesh tape is often marketed as a time-saver, it can lead to more sanding and joint compound application later, which may add to labor costs. "You may save time initially with mesh tape, but think of the time and material costs in the long haul," warns financial analyst for the construction industry, Mark Smith.

Final Verdict: Choosing the Best Tape for Inside Corners

In conclusion, the choice between mesh tape and paper tape ultimately comes down to the specific requirements of your project and personal preference. If you're in a hurry and require immediate results, mesh tape might be the way to go. However, if you prioritize durability and strength, especially for inside corners that require extra care, paper tape is generally the best choice according to an overwhelming consensus among experts.

Before you proceed with your drywall project, weigh these considerations and expert insights to choose the best tape for inside corners, ensuring a professional finish that stands the test of time.

For more information, please visit mesh tape for inside corners, how to mesh tape drywall, fiberglass mesh vs wire mesh.